Doktoro Esperanto

ROMAN MARS: This is 99% Invisible. I’m Roman Mars, and I’m here today with friend of the show and frequent 99PI contributor Katie Thornton. Hey Katie, what do you have for us today? 

KATIE THORNTON: Hey, Roman. So, a while back, I was on this show talking about shortwave radio. Unlike FM or AM radio, shortwave signals are those ones that can travel thousands of miles. 

ROMAN MARS: Yeah, you could be sitting in your place in Minnesota and hear a broadcast in Spanish from South America or something with shortwave. 

KATIE THORNTON: Yeah, exactly. And it’s actually the language part that I wanted to talk with you about today because, one day, as I was researching and poking around on the shortwaves, I learned something that really surprised me. Roman, did you know that the Chinese national government and, until recently, the Vatican aired programs on shortwave radio in–drum roll please–Esperanto. 

ROMAN MARS: Esperanto! The invented language of Esperanto. I’m a big fan. 

KATIE THORNTON: Okay, yeah, so in fact, the Vatican, to this day, still does a thrice weekly podcast in Esperanto. 

VATICAN RADIO: Informojn pri la papo…Radio Vatikana. Vatikanaj novaĵoj en Esperanto…

ROMAN MARS: Wow, okay, so for the dedicated 99PI fans, we did an episode on Esperanto way back in I think it was 2010. I think it was, like, the first year of the show. But for people who didn’t hear that story or simply don’t know or remember, because I don’t remember what’s in that story, what should we say here about Esperanto? 

KATIE THORNTON: So Esperanto is what linguists call a “constructed language.” The language isn’t attached to a nation or a region, and it didn’t evolve from some other language over time. Instead, nearly 150 years ago, someone decided to sit down, probably at a desk with a pen and paper, and just make it whole cloth. 

ROMAN MARS: Or as we see on the show, they designed it. 

KATIE THORNTON: Yes, of course. Right. Of course, I’m sorry, they designed it. And from the very beginning, the goal behind this designed language was to make it incredibly easy to learn. That way, everyone in the world would just voluntarily take it up. And once that happened, we’d all be able to understand one another. And of course, from there, the idea went, world peace would follow. 

ROMAN MARS: Yeah, big goals! 

KATIE THORNTON: Big goals! Kind of the biggest goal. So, you know, when I first came across this Vatican Esperanto thing, it really sent me down this crazy months’–I guess even years’–long rabbit hole, so much so that I actually took to Duolingo to learn Esperanto. 

KATIE THORNTON: Uh, post mi laboris… In the past. Mi dormis…  After I worked, I slept. Same, bro. Cha-ching…

ROMAN MARS: Well, since you’re at least Duolingo-versed in Esperanto, I should say… Saluton Katie, mia nomo estas Roman.

KATIE THORNTON: Ho, vi komprenas Esperanton!

ROMAN MARS: A little bit. I mean, that’s just, like, “Hi, Katie, my name is Roman.” And then you replied, “Oh, you understand Esperanto?” which I don’t actually. But I did dabble in Esperanto a little bit when I was younger. I was taught it in second grade, probably the last elementary school program in the United States to ever teach Esperanto as far as I can tell. But that experience really stuck with me. 

KATIE THORNTON: Wow, okay. So, unlike you, I was never an Esperantist, but I remember hearing about the language as a teenager. And at the time, I was definitely interested in the idea of a language that was rooted in this idea of mutual understanding and belonging, even if it was a bit overly earnest. But you know, I also was in high school and working and doing life, so I sort of forgot about it, honestly. 

ROMAN MARS: Yeah, life happens and you put Esperanto on the back burner. 

KATIE THORNTON: It’s true–sad, but true. But then this past summer, I revisited Esperanto for a story I reported in Harper’s Magazine because I was curious. Like, in a world that is as divided as ours, I wanted to know why this group still believes in the power of this language to bring about peace. And if they do indeed believe that, where does that optimism come from? And look, this isn’t a story where I come out the other side convinced that Esperanto is going to solve all of our problems. But I do think there’s something we can all learn from the people who are keeping this old, invented language alive. 

ROMAN MARS: Okay, so let’s start from the beginning. Where did Esperanto originally come from? 

KATIE THORNTON: Yes. So, I’ll kick things off in the late 1800s in a town called Bialystok. 

BRIGID O’KEEFFE: This was a town that was home to people of a variety of different ethnicities and religions and languages spoken in the home. 

KATIE THORNTON: This is Brigid O’Keeffe, a historian of the Soviet Union and professor at Brooklyn College. She wrote a book about Esperanto and internationalism. 

BRIGID O’KEEFFE: You had Poles. You had Jews. You had Russians. You had Germans. Bialystok was part of a very multi-ethnic borderland region of the Czarist Empire. 

KATIE THORNTON: If you were to look at a map today, Bialystok is a city on the eastern border of Poland. But in the 19th century, it was part of something called the Pale of Settlement, which was the area of the Russian Empire where Jews were allowed to live permanently. 

ROMAN MARS: Which they really couldn’t do in the rest of the Russian Empire. 

KATIE THORNTON: Right. And so this is where, in 1859, a kid named L.L. Zamenhof is born. 

Growing up in Bialystok, Zamenhof spoke Yiddish, Russian, and Polish. And later he learned French, Latin, Greek, Hebrew, and English. 

ROMAN MARS: [CHUCKLES] Show-off!

KATIE THORNTON: I know. Such a flex. He didn’t even have Duolingo. How did he do it? But in learning all these languages, he was also keenly aware of the tension that came with all these differences. 

BRIGID O’KEEFFE: What he remembered most of all were insults and bickering and acrimony and just, like, an undercurrent in the marketplace, in the town square of animosity, mistrust. 

KATIE THORNTON: So from a pretty young age, Zamenhof had this idea to bring the world together under one language. Here’s Brigid paraphrasing a piece of a letter that Zamenhoff wrote. 

BRIGID O’KEEFFE: “In my soul, in my own little aching child’s heart, I thought to myself, ‘So much of this tension, so much this animosity, so of this mistrust would be obviated if only we had a common mode, a common register, a common language through which to talk.'” 

KATIE THORNTON: And so as a kid, Zamenhof started constructing a language that he reasoned would be easy for anyone to learn. And if it was also fun to learn, he figured people would opt into it as a second language. And voilà, marketplace arguments over. 

ROMAN MARS: I’m sort of struck by the sort of childlike approach to Zamenhof’s project. Kids sometimes will create a secret code so they can talk to one another so that nobody understands them. But this is, like, the total opposite of that. 

KATIE THORNTON: Complete opposite of that. Yeah, he wanted everybody to speak it. So starting when he was pretty young, Zamenhof crafted the rules of his language. And in 1887, before his 30th birthday, he compiled all those rules and published what’s called The First Book, or Unua Libro. 

ROMAN MARS: And this is the founding text, like the Bible, so to speak, for Esperanto. 

KATIE THORNTON: Yeah, so this book was actually written in Russian. So, technically, the book’s title is just International Language. And Zamenhof actually wrote it under the pen name Doktoro Esperanto, which in his own language means “one who hopes.”

ROMAN MARS: So “Esperanto” comes from that pen name, “Doktoro Esperanto?”

KATIE THORNTON: Yeah, he did not actually name this thing Esperanto. That was all the work of the fans. 

ROMAN MARS: They took the name, like Dr. Frankenstein and Frankenstein. 

KATIE THORNTON: Yes, it’s exactly like that. And in this book, Zamenhof, or Doktoro Esperanto, lays out the language’s ideology of unity and peace. But mostly what he does is outline the grammar, the word structure, really the design of the language. 

BRIGID O’KEEFFE: The way that Zamenhof designed the language was to give birth to a kind of core vocabulary of some 700, 900 core root words. 

KATIE THORNTON: So what Zamenhof does is make it so that all of the parts of speech–nouns, adjectives, adverbs, verbs–have a consistent ending. 

ROMAN MARS: This is the best part of Esperanto, so please explain this a little bit more. 

KATIE THORNTON: Yeah, of course, it’s so good! Nouns end in “O,” so “sano” is “health.” Adjectives end in “A.” “Sana” is “healthy.” “Verbs” end in “I,” so “sani,” “to be healthy.”

ROMAN MARS: And there are also the prefixes and suffixes that modify, like mal indicates the opposite. And so, like, “sana” is “healthy,” but “mal sana” is “sick.”

KATIE THORNTON: Yeah, okay, look at you, Roman, reaching back to your Esperanto roots and prefixes and affixes. But yes, that’s exactly right. It’s really clear, really simple, and consistent. Esperanto advocates like to say that you can understand the vast majority of the language just from knowing about 500 plug-and-play root words and affixes. 

BRIGID O’KEEFFE: And so while he kind of gave the language its original architecture and gave it its original vocabulary, so much of even the earliest vocabulary was just developed in the practice of, at first, a dozen and then dozens and then hundreds and then thousands and then tens of thousands of people actually putting the language into practice. 

KATIE THORNTON: So I should say, Zamenhof wasn’t the first to think of creating a universal second language. In the late 1800s, attempts at creating something like Esperanto were actually pretty common. New technologies like railroads were connecting people across huge distances, and there was this notion that maybe language would be the next great divide to fall. But unlike those other attempts, Esperanto actually caught on. 

ROMAN MARS: But I’m curious, how does that happen? How does word get out about Esperanto? 

KATIE THORNTON: Yeah, so the language isn’t just growing because it’s easy to learn. Of course that helps. But on top of everything, Zamenhof is also kind of a marketing mastermind. So in the back of the Unua Libro, there were these little pre-printed notes that you could tear out of the book saying that you promised to learn Esperanto. And people would essentially make these pledges–these promises–and then mail these back to Zamenhof personally. 

BRIGID O’KEEFFE: Whenever an Esperantist or a young early adopter or even someone just curious wrote to him, he would reply. But what he would also do is he started creating an address book, a directory of people who signed their names, who had committed to learning the language, and who had expressed interest in corresponding or communicating in it. 

ROMAN MARS: This is so amazing. So people are sending their pledges into Zamenhof. And then he’s compiling basically, like, a directory of speakers. And then does he publish this directory? 

KATIE THORNTON: Yeah, you could go get your own copy of it. And people would write letters to other Esperantists. It was a really big grassroots movement. The Unua Libro, with the grammar and everything, had to be reprinted within six months of its debut. And by the turn of the century, the movement had gained enough momentum to really begin to organize. 

BRIGID O’KEEFFE: In 1905, for the first time in world history, a group of electing Esperantists travel to France as participants in the first World Congress of Esperantists. 

KATIE THORNTON: This first World Congress of Esperantists is really just a fancy way of saying that they held a convention. And at this first convention, nearly 700 people joined from more than 20 countries. 

BRIGID O’KEEFFE: They found that Esperanto could actually work in real life, right? It could work in live conversation. It had a life beyond the page, right? It allowed them to meet people and to talk to people and have fun with people and to realize, you know, like, “Oh, I’ve been spending hours with these people and I’m not thinking about them as Frenchmen or as Englishmen or as Russians or as Jews. I’m thinking about them as people.”

ROMAN MARS: So this is clearly a big deal, and that’s a lot of people to get together from so many different places in 1905. But, like, beyond the convention, is it well known? Is Esperanto really in the zeitgeist? 

KATIE THORNTON: Oh, absolutely. You know, it was an explicitly internationalist project, so it particularly took off among leftist groups, like international labor organizers and anarchists. It also had some big-name boosters. I mean, maybe you’ve heard of a guy with just a little bit of influence, this Christian anarchist pacifist, Leo Tolstoy. So, Tolstoy took it upon himself to learn Esperanto. Ho Chi Minh learned it while living in London. And actually, George Soros’ father, who was born Tivadar Schwartz, changed his family’s last name to the Esperanto word meaning “will soar.” And that was to avoid antisemitic persecution in his native Hungary. 

ROMAN MARS: I did not know that at all. That’s amazing. 

KATIE THORNTON: A lot of prominent speakers–a ton of speakers. I mean, this was really a thing at the time. 

ROMAN MARS: But what I’m wondering is, like, all this popularity and growth is happening… It actually presents this challenge for a designed language like Esperanto because as soon as more people start speaking it, don’t they start changing the language with their own verb tenses and their own slang? Like, doesn’t it stop from being this fixed universal second language into something that evolves naturally like natural languages do? 

KATIE THORNTON: Yeah, so that does begin to happen. And it’s a really big concern for the early Esperantists. So, at that first annual convention in France, some Esperantists at Zamenhof’s urging formed what came to be called the Esperanto Academy, which is basically a governing body for the language to keep Esperanto from changing uncontrollably. 

ROMAN MARS: And this is actually pretty common. Like lots of languages, they have their own institutions that regulate linguistic standards. 

KATIE THORNTON: Yes, definitely. There’s one in Spain for Spanish. 

ROMAN MARS: But the goal is a little bit different because with Spanish and French academies, the goal is to define a national identity around the language. But in Esperanto, the goal is to keep it simple, straightforward, consistent, so that it as a language can transcend all national boundaries. 

KATIE THORNTON: Yeah. That’s right. And it did do that. Esperanto is rooted in European languages, but it didn’t just take off in Europe. It found an early foothold in Asia and eventually around the globe. And for a lot of early speakers, this was all part of the plan. 

ROMAN MARS: So, what do you mean here by “the plan?”

KATIE THORNTON: Okay, so we mentioned that the idea behind this language was that everybody would speak it, understand one another, inevitably there would be peace. For a lot of the early Esperantists, that wasn’t just a sort of passing idea, it was a real political project. From the early days of the language, people in the Esperanto movement had this concept called the “fina venko,” “final victory,” that would occur when everyone in the world, including governments, would take up Esperanto as a second language, and the people would be united in a shared tongue. It’s an ideology that came to be known as “finvenkismo.”

ROMAN MARS: That’s pretty intense. I don’t like any political movements that are the “final” anything, to tell you the truth. 

KATIE THORNTON: Yeah. Me neither. But in the early 1900s, finvenkismo felt possible. The language was reaching all kinds of people. 

ROMAN MARS: But you know, we’re not all speaking Esperanto today, so of course, at some point, this all must start to flicker out. 

KATIE THORNTON: Yeah, big time. 

BRIGID O’KEEFFE: Precisely in that decade where Esperanto was truly taking off– It was truly having its moment, right? There were kind of factions that argued that Esperanto is great, but it could be better. We could fine tune this and perfect this more. 

KATIE THORNTON: So in 1907 comes the first major, what I’ll call, “I have a better idea” moment. And it comes in the form of a new language called Ido. The Ido speakers–or the Idists–were originally Esperantists. In fact, the name “Ido” actually comes from the Esperanto affix meaning “offspring.” And the Idists created what was essentially Esperanto with even more straightforward grammar and even more simplified vocabulary. And all this tinkering with the language really started to divide the Esperanto movement. 

BRIGID O’KEEFFE: When you’re really passionate about something, you can miss the forest for the trees and you can forget your audience. And it was one of the things that was illustrative of how the Esperanto movement got in its own way. 

KATIE THORNTON: So, this missing the forest for the trees thing just keeps happening because, as the language grew and by design welcomed all sorts of people, the foundational aspirations of Esperanto kept being tested. 

BRIGID O’KEEFFE: The movement itself had an extraordinary tendency to create its own splinters. We have bourgeois Esperantists over here. We have socialist Esperantists over here. We have anarchist Esperantists over here. 

ROMAN MARS: There’s something ironic about the fact that there are these bitter rifts that are breaking out inside of this language that’s supposed to be bringing us all together. 

KATIE THORNTON: Definitely. And of course, like that is not exclusive to Esperanto. 

ROMAN MARS: Not at all.

KATIE THORNTON: It happens in all sorts of movements. People genuinely want to come together. They are desperate to come together. But sometimes one of the biggest barriers to actually living in harmony is a disagreement over the best way to live in harmony. 

ROMAN MARS: Yeah, it’s deeply frustrating but also deeply human. 

KATIE THORNTON: Yeah, and also kind of beautiful in its own right. And so all along, there are certainly internal forces that are fracturing the Esperantists. But soon, external forces begin to really reshape the movement as well. So in the 1920s and ’30s, nationalists were growing in power around the world. And they swiftly moved to end all internationalist agendas. So Franco, Stalin, and Hitler’s regimes all criminalized Esperanto and sometimes executed Esperantists. The Nazis even murdered all three of Zamenhof’s children. 

ROMAN MARS: Oh, god. And yet, still, somehow the language survived. 

KATIE THORNTON: Right. Yeah, it was certainly seen as a threat, it was actively repressed, and it would never again be as popular as it was before the Second World War. But when the most violent repression eased after the war, Esperanto once again had a bit of a boom, this time during the Cold War, both among young people in the Soviet Union who wanted to connect with people in Western Europe, but also among folks in Eastern Europe who were trying to resist the sort of snowballing hegemony of the West and of the English language. 

ROMAN MARS: And I know from personal experience that it kind of bloomed again in this sort of, like, you know, hippie intellectual movement, the post-hippie movement, in the ’70s and ’80s. 

KATIE THORNTON: That’s right. And then in the ’90s, there’s a big community of speakers who brought the language online and made it easier for more and more people to learn on the web. 

ROMAN MARS: Yeah. Yeah, it’s on Duolingo for Jesuo sake, yeah. 

KATIE THORNTON: Cha-ching! So there you go, Zamenhof, we really did it. 

ROMAN MARS: Yeah, I mean, I guess that really brings us back to where we started. You learned Esperanto last year, so did you end up speaking with any Esperantists for this story? 

KATIE THORNTON: Yeah, I did. So there’s, of course, a thriving community of Esperantists online, Facebook groups, subreddits, but I really wanted to meet people, like, in person, and find out who are these folks who are still learning and speaking this 19th century language that was supposed to bring peace to the world. So, last summer, I flew halfway around the world to Brno, a small city in the Czech Republic because, for eight days, more than a thousand Esperantists from all over were gathered here for the World Esperanto Congress. 

ROMAN MARS: Eight days! 

KATIE THORNTON: Eight days. 

ROMAN MARS: Eight days, amazing. So that convention happens every year? 

KATIE THORNTON: Every year, Roman. And while it’s happening, everyone basically only speaks Esperanto. Also, I should say the Esperantists prefer to call it the Universala Kongreso de Esperanto.

ROMAN MARS: Okay, so after the break, Katie reports from the Universala Kongreso de Esperanto. Stay with us. 

[AD BREAK]

CONVENTION SPEAKER: Saluton kaj bonenon al Brno! Kongresanoj…

ROMAN MARS: Okay, so we’re back. And we’re at the convention. And I think someone said something like, “Hello and welcome to Brno.”

KATIE THORNTON: Hey! Not bad for someone who only dabbled in Esperanto 40 years ago. But yes, I’m there in Brno with more than a thousand Esperanto speakers from 62 different countries. And when I arrived at the convention, I was kind of shocked to see the breadth of people speaking Esperanto. There were, as ever, the anarchists and the European social democrats. But there were also folks from a state-approved Chinese Esperantist group. Delegation from the Catholic Church, Ukrainian independence advocates… 

ROMAN MARS: So, like, really a range of people from all over with perhaps a pretty wide range of political views. 

KATIE THORNTON: Yeah, and that surprised me. I assumed I’d be running into a lot of left-leaning, American nerdy types–no offense, of course–but that wasn’t really the case. And I also presumed that the convention would be pretty in line with the traditional goals of Esperanto–a lot of talk about the language, about how the movement can bring about peace–and there was a bit of that. But what I didn’t expect was that most people didn’t really talk much about those ideals at all. 

So I want to get to that, but let’s start with the old-school stuff and what was maybe the most traditional of all the sessions at the convention: the public meeting of the Akademio de Esperanto, or the Esperanto Academy. 

ROMAN MARS: Oh, so the Esperanto Academy, it still exists. 

KATIE THORNTON: It does still exist. And they still do largely the same job that they started back in 1905. They hold public meetings and discuss how the language is evolving. Now, before you get your hopes up for a raucous session full of debate about grammar and syntax, I want to explain that this was not the most thrilling session that I went to at the convention. There was no shouting matches. There honestly weren’t that many people there even. But you know, sometimes this is what democracy looks like–slow, a little boring, kind of poorly attended. 

ROMAN MARS: And so what was happening in this session? 

KATIE THORNTON: Yeah, so, basically, people were submitting questions on pieces of paper. At one point, somebody submitted a question about why the language doesn’t yet have a great and broadly accepted gender neutral pronoun. 

ROMAN MARS: That’s a good question. 

KATIE THORNTON: Totally valid question. So the Academy took that under advisement. There was also a question from a violin repair person asking why there weren’t more words for stringed instruments in the latest official dictionary. 

ROMAN MARS: Fun. 

KATIE THORNTON: So the questions–they really ran the gamut. 

ROMAN MARS: So did you muster up some courage and ask a question of the Academy? 

KATIE THORNTON: I did not feel that I’m a competent enough Esperanto speaker to know of any missing words or confusing grammar. But I did get to talk with an organizer who helped set up the Congress. His name is Petro Baláž. And what I learned from talking with him and others is that the academy is a pretty reactive group. Like, they don’t want to upset their fellow Esperantists. So, once a word or a way of speaking becomes commonplace within the community, the academy kind of reviews it. And often they make a recommendation that others adopt it too. 

PETRO BALÁŽ: Of course, they are only the recommendations because the community of Esperantists there more tend to be like anarchists. 

ROMAN MARS: Okay, so tell me more about Petro. What’s going on with Petro? 

KATIE THORNTON: Yeah, Petro was born in then Czechoslovakia. And he started learning and speaking Esperanto a few years after watching his country split in two. And he told me that Esperanto speakers these days come to the Congress not necessarily to talk about grammar and syntax. They come for the community and for the camaraderie. 

ROMAN MARS: And did you see that play out at the Congress? 

KATIE THORNTON: Yes, I definitely did. Like, many of the most spirited and well-attended sessions at the convention weren’t the super-official things like the academy session that I went to. Instead, there was a lot of energy around the hobbies and the social gatherings. 

PETRO BALÁŽ: So you can meet here, like, linguists professors. You can meet chess players or go players and whatever. 

KATIE THORNTON: So, over the course of the trip, I met, yes, Esperantist chess players and go players. There were also bicycle enthusiasts and stamp collectors. Even Esperanto nudists had events. Like, they went to a nude beach and they all crammed on this public tram to get there for a half hour. And I mean, maybe the hottest ticket of the entire week, or at least a personal favorite of mine, was a presentation by the International Federation of Esperanto Railway Men. 

ROMAN MARS: The train people. I love the train people. 

KATIE THORNTON: Of course, the train people absolutely rocked, fantastic presentation, history of trains in Brno and beyond. 

ROMAN MARS: I mean, this all sounds fun and funny, but it all makes total sense. Like, you’re an Esperanto speaker at an Esperanto convention, you want to have fun. You want to speak the language. You don’t want to just debate world peace or whatever goals–these high-minded goals–that maybe get nowhere. You want to talk about trains. 

KATIE THORNTON: Absolutely. Of course you want to talk about trains. But you know, the convention hasn’t always been this sort of fun social gathering. That dynamic is actually the result of a pivotal moment for the movement. So, back in 1980, at an Esperanto youth congress in the Finnish city of Rauma, a group of speakers had an epiphany. They were like, “Hey, all these grand ambitions for world peace and universal second language, they’re really sort of weighing the movement down. So, let’s just close the book on all that.”

ROMAN MARS: So they’re basically kind of giving up on that big idea–the finvenkismo idea–that Esperanto would be universally adopted by everyone as a second language. 

KATIE THORNTON: Yeah, that’s right. And at the time, in 1980, the language had been around for nearly a century. That final victory hadn’t happened yet. So this group of young folks proposed that the language be viewed more as a community-building tool and that Esperantists should consider themselves, quote, “as belonging to a self-chosen, diasporic, linguistic minority.”

ROMAN MARS: Yeah, so in essence, they’re allowing for and kind of accepting the idea that Esperanto would be a subculture. 

KATIE THORNTON: Yeah. Like, it didn’t have to be universally adopted in order to have value. 

ROMAN MARS: You know, I love that there’s this formal acknowledgement that the language has some limitations but there’s still a desire to keep it anyway and to have it be a thing that people share. But I can’t imagine the final victory folks enjoyed this capitulation at all. 

KATIE THORNTON: No, they did not. The finvenkismo folks did not like this. But, you know, based on what I saw at the congress last year, the subculture school of thought really seems to have sort of won out. 

ROMAN MARS: But what about this old Esperantist thought, you know, the goal of using this language explicitly to promote world peace? Like, I can’t imagine the spirit of that is totally gone. 

KATIE THORNTON: No, it’s not totally gone. I had some really interesting conversations with very politically dedicated Esperantists, and that peacenik school of thought has lived on in some unlikely places. 

As an example, I spoke with a man named Espoir Ngoma Kasati, and he’s from the DRC, the Democratic Republic of the Congo. And the DRC is one of the most linguistically diverse nations in the world. It has more than 200 languages, and it has also been struggling with a brutal conflict. And Espoir is part of a contingent trying to advance a pacifist movement by bringing people together under one shared language. 

ESPOIR NGOMA KASATI:   Moltaj junuloj en Afriko parolas Esperantoj. En pluraj diversaj, uh, do, malsamaj landoj. Yes, vere moltaj. 

KATIE THORNTON: Did you get that, Roman? 

ROMAN MARS: [CHUCKLES] Like, a little. Like, he’s saying that many Africans speak Esperanto–a very diverse group of people speak it–something like that. 

KATIE THORNTON: Yeah, so he’s basically saying that many young Africans in many different countries speak Esperanto. 

ESPOIR NGOMA KASATI: Jes, ni pensas, ke Esperanto estas bona por Afriko, char, ji ne estas kolonia lingvo.

KATIE THORNTON: And he says that he and his colleagues feel the language is good for Africa because it’s not a colonial language. 

ROMAN MARS: I mean, this is an excellent point. Like, they’re gathering people from all over the world in this Congress and these big ideas and they’re all speaking the same language and, for once, it is not English. 

KATIE THORNTON: Absolutely. It’s a huge accomplishment. And I think, these days, Esperantists, broadly speaking, sort of recognize the utility of having the more politically devout side of the movement exist alongside the subculturists. So at the convention, I spoke with a scholar and a prominent Esperantist named Humphrey Tonkin. He was 85 years old at the time. He’s a very, very accomplished guy. He was the president of a college. He’s a scholar of literature. In the Esperanto world, he’s definitely a get. And he put it this way, which I really liked. 

HUMPHREY TONKIN: If you are into the English-speaking peace movement, what are you doing there? Peace. So you talk about peace. You talk about it really seriously. And you, in fact, probably talk about it so seriously that you bore the hell out of people. It’s not like that in the Esperanto movement because we have a whole culture that we can fall back on. 

KATIE THORNTON: So, most people I spoke with had no delusions about the language’s potential. They knew that unlocking world peace is a goal that’s poignantly out of their hands. But what the Esperantists did show me is that, even amid our global turmoil, they still found it worthwhile to get together to try to enact the ideals of peace and understanding, even if only on a small scale and even if only among one another.

ROMAN MARS: Yeah, like, the movement might not bring the peace that Zamenhof dreamed of, but it might bring some measure of peace and understanding to the people who speak it. 

KATIE THORNTON: Right. And look, it’s easy to think of that as an overly optimistic and simplistic idea. And I don’t think that’s wrong. Like, sometimes people can fully comprehend one another and still disagree, still even hate each other. Language alone isn’t going to erase hatred. But almost everyone I spoke with said that this gathering gives them hope. I mean, the idea of hope is baked right into the name of the language. 

HUMPHREY TONKIN: The point about hope, though, is that you never achieve your goal. That’s not what it’s about. It’s about looking at the world in an optimistic way and working for something that is positive and that will benefit humankind. I don’t think that, among Esperantists, there’s a great deal of emphasis on the antagonisms. What we look for is what we have in common, which doesn’t mean we’re always successful. It doesn’t mean that I don’t get infuriated by many of my fellow Esperantists. And we argue in Esperanto, you know? 

ROMAN MARS: I mean, it strikes me that this is a group of people that are just absolutely completely devoted to trying to learn something from the differences of each other and to try to embrace those differences and find common ground. 

KATIE THORNTON: Yeah, there’s this sort of shameless love for humanity in the Esperanto world that really seems to have fallen out of fashion most everywhere else. And that’s not an impulse I’m eager to beat back with obvious critiques, especially critiques that the Esperantists themselves are fully aware of. Look, I know that, in 2026, the Esperanto-speaking community is almost uncomfortably earnest. Some would say it’s cringe. But I think we could all afford to be a little more cringe. 

INTERNACIA KORUSO: [SINGING] Vee vay voh…

KATIE THORNTON: So, Roman, there’s one more thing I wanted to tell you about from my time in Brno, and that’s that I actually decided to join the daily practices of the Internacia Koruso, or International Chorus. 

ROMAN MARS: Did you actually join the Esperanto choir? 

KATIE THORNTON: There’s an Esperanto choir, and I had to join it. I mean, I’m not a singer-singer, but I’ve played instruments and sung in bands since I was a teenager, so I figured I’d give it a try. 

ROMAN MARS: I love it. 

KATIE THORNTON: So, yeah, on the final night of the convention, all the attendees went back to the big concert hall where the opening ceremony was held. And the night ended with us! Our scrappy little choir sang a local Czech folk tune and a Mozart song that was actually translated by Zamenhof himself. But our showstopper, I think, was an Esperanto translation of the Latin hymn “Dona nobis pacem,” “Grant us peace,” or in Esperanto, “Donu al ni pacon.” Look, are we in tune? Not really. But are we trying to find harmony together? Yes, we are. And we’re doing so in not one but two constructed languages, Esperanto, of course, but also musical notation. That’s a universal constructed language, too. And no one bats an eye at it. 

ROMAN MARS: Good point. I mean, this performance may be a little off-key. But it seems to me such a fitting end to your convention because this is what Esperanto is all about, right? It’s trying to come together, even if it’s imperfect. 

KATIE THORNTON: I think that’s right. 

ROMAN MARS: Okay, well, thank you so much for this story. It’s been fun to revisit Esperanto. 

KATIE THORNTON: Thanks for talking with me, Roman. Adiaŭ. 

ROMAN MARS: Adiaŭ.

99% Invisible was produced this week by Katie Thorton. Edited by Jayson De Leon. Mix by Martín Gonzalez. Music by Swan Real. Fact-checking by Graham Hacia. Katie Thornton’s feature, Love Language: The Undying Dream of Esperanto, ran in the June edition of Harper’s, and you can find it online. It was supported by NYU’s Matthew Power Literary Reporting Award, which we wanted to mention to all you audio-making listeners out there is now open to applicants who work in audio, not just in print. 

Kathy Tu is our executive producer. Kurt Kohlstedt is our digital director. Delaney Hall is our senior editor. The rest of the team includes Chris Berube, Emmett FitzGerald, Christopher Johnson, Vivian Le, Lasha Madan, Joe Rosenberg, Kelly Prime, Jeyca Medina-Gleason, Talon and Rain Stradley, and me, Roman Mars. The 99% Invisible logo was created by Stefan Lawrence. 

We are part of the SiriusXM Podcast Family, now headquartered six blocks north in the Pandora building… in beautiful… uptown… Oakland, California. You can find us on all the usual social media sites, as well as our Discord server. There’s a link to that, as well as every past episode of 99PI, at 99pi.org.

Credits

Production

99% Invisible was produced this week by Katie Thorton. Edited by Jayson De Leon. Mix by Martín Gonzalez. Music by Swan Real. Fact-checking by Graham Hacia.

  1. Daniel Przybylski

    William Shatner starred in the 1966 movie, ‘Incubus’, an American movie with dialog in Esperanto. Described by someone on IMDb as Ingmar Bergman meets ‘The Outer Limits’.

  2. Daniel Przybylski

    William Shatner starred in the 1966 production ‘Incubus’, an American film with dialog completely in Esperanto. Someone on IMDb describes it as Ingmar Bergman meets ‘The Outer Limits’.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All Categories

Minimize Maximize

Playlist